Total Pageviews

Tuesday, September 8, 2026

HOF Insights- The Real Value of High School Sports








In the “HOF Insights”, I ask a group of successful, veteran coaches to share their thoughts on a variety of topics. Each week, I ask a different question. The questions can be focused on helping coaches, parents or athletes to have a more successful athletic experience.  

It seems like more and more parents feel that the only purpose of high school sports is to get a college scholarship. This leads some parents and players to feel that they need to specialize and just focus on one sport- get personal trainers and spend thousands of dollars on travel teams. 

As coaches, we want our athletes to always strive to be the best they can be, but we also want them to enjoy their high school athletic experience. 

What advice would you give parents and athletes to maximize their potential and to take advantage of their high school athletic experience?




Kimberly Barth- Washington (Girls Basketball)























As a (retired) high school basketball coach and state championship coach, I have spent many years watching young athletes develop—not only as players, but as people. That experience has shaped my belief that athletes and families should be very cautious about specializing in one sport at an early age simply because they believe it will increase their chances of earning a college scholarship.

The reality is that very few high school athletes ultimately receive Division I athletic scholarships. With such a small percentage reaching that level, I believe it is important for families to keep the college scholarship conversation in perspective. A scholarship should be viewed as a possible outcome of development and opportunity—not the sole reason a young athlete plays a sport.

There is tremendous value in being a multi-sport athlete. Playing different sports allows young athletes to develop different skills, movement patterns, decision-making abilities, competitiveness, confidence, and leadership qualities. Just as importantly, participating in multiple sports can help athletes maintain their enjoyment of competition and avoid the physical and mental burnout that can come with playing one sport year-round.

Some athletes will eventually reach a point where specializing makes sense, and that decision should be based on the individual athlete, their goals, their development, and guidance from knowledgeable coaches. But I would encourage families not to believe that early specialization is a requirement for playing college athletics.

I would also encourage parents to look beyond the scholarship itself. Colleges are looking for much more than athletic ability. Character, academics, work ethic, leadership, coachability, resilience, and the ability to be a great teammate all matter. The athlete who spends their high school years becoming a well-rounded person may ultimately be better prepared for college—and for life—than the athlete who focuses exclusively on one sport.

As coaches and parents, our responsibility is to help young people develop a love for competition, learn how to work through adversity, become dependable teammates, and understand the value of commitment and hard work. If a college athletic opportunity comes from that development, it is something to celebrate.

But the goal should never be to chase a scholarship at the expense of the athlete.

Develop the person. Develop the athlete. Let the opportunities follow.




Mike Cooper- Ottawa (Girls Basketball, Athletic Director)























Parents who push their kids to specialize in a specific sport are missing the purpose of high school sports! I can't tell you how many kids get to be juniors and seniors in high school and they have lost their desire to play just one sport. Very few athletes have the commitment level to only play one sport 12 months of the year despite what their parents think. 


If you are traveling for practice and tournaments you are probably missing fun activities at your school with your friends. Most players have major regrets when they finish high school and look back on their playing days. A good number of the players tell themselves I wish I would have played some other sports. If you're good enough to specialize you are probably a very good athlete that would excel at other sports. 


When you specialize it is usually very expensive to play on a travel team. The cost to join the team, travel to practice and tournaments, hotel rooms and entry fees to go to the games for parents is very costly and can be very stressful for a family. When you travel for tournaments you are probably missing school which can be an issue for those who struggle with grades.


Almost all college coaches look for players who play multiple sports and participate in different activities. They are looking for well-rounded athletes. You only have one chance to be a high school athlete before going to college or entering work world, don't miss out on school activities with your friends! 




Greg Bennett- Lewistown (Track, Football, Girls Basketball, Athletic Director)






















It definitely is sad that many high school athletes, and even more often their parents, have a belief that specialization and year around sport specific activity will lead them to the “promised land” of a “full-ride” Division 1 scholarship. 


Such scholarships are actually quite rare, as fewer than 1% of all high school athletes ever receive full-ride athletic scholarships for college. In fact, out of the roughly 8 million high school student-athletes in the U.S., only about 2% earn ANY athletic scholarship money whatsoever.


The true purpose of high school sports is to build character in individuals, by developing attributes such as teamwork, perseverance, mental toughness, responsibility, and leadership. As this is the case, I would advise students and their parents to focus on the positive benefits of athletic competition in general, instead of obsessing over potential scholarships and professional careers.


Specializing in one sport, in hopes of getting a scholarship, actually tends to hamper overall athletic development. It also puts unnecessary pressure on students to fulfill unrealistic expectations, and often leads to problems such as overuse injuries and mental burnout. Furthermore, it tends to breakdown the team concept of sport,  as individuals focus on their own statistics instead of the overall execution and success of the team.


Many parents also fall into the trap of “AAU type programs,” that lure them in by hyping scholarship opportunities, but, more often than not, simply cause them to spend large amounts money on entry fees, private coaching, travel expenses, etc. In fact, I have seen numerous instances where parents spent so much money pursuing scholarships, that never materialized, than they would have actually spent paying for their child’s college tuition. 



For another view on the topic…


HOF Insights: Thom Sigel: Shares the Values & Joy of HS Sports



Past articles in the HOF Insights series….


HOF Insights- Past Articles




HOF Insights- Coaching Panel

Bob Anderson- Williamsfield (Boys Basketball)

Bob is retired as boys basketball coach at Williamsfield. At a school of only 89 students, in 45 years, his teams won 732 games along with numerous tourney and conference championships. His 1997 team made it to the Elite 8. 

Kimberly Barth- Washington (Girls Basketball)

Greg Bennett- Lewistown (Football, Track, Girls Basketball)
Greg coached many sports at Lewistown. He had teams go to State in girls basketball and football. He is in the Illinois Football HOF as well as being in the Illinois Basketball Hall of Fame. He is know for his commitment as a coach and his high energy level. 

Todd Borrison- Preston, Assumption, Camanche, Mediapolis (Girls Basketball)

Kathy Bresnahan- Iowa City West (Volleyball)
Kathy coached volleyball at Iowa City West from 1987-2000 and 2005-2013. Her teams made 7 State apprearances and won the State Championship in 2010 and 2011. She wrote a book, “The Miracle Season” about the 2011 season, which was made into a movie. She was National COY in 2011, State COY 2010, 2011. She is in both the Iowa Volleyball HOF and UW-Platteville HOF. 

Debbie Coffman- Bloomington CC (Girls Basketball)

Mark Cooper- Ottawa (Boys Basketball)

Mike Cooper- Ottawa HS (Football, Girls Basketball)
Mike is the retired Athletic Director at Ottawa HS. He was varsity girls basketball coach for 22 years, as well as sophomore football coach for many years. He was inducted in the the IBCA HOF.

Tim Engebretson- United HS (Football)
He was varsity head football coach for many years at United HS. He also has coached basketball at different levels. His 2005 team won the Illinois State Title, and Tim is in the Illinois Football Coaches' HOF as well as the United HOF.

Ralph Gallo- Richwoods (Girls Basketball)

Jay Hatch- Alleman, Riverdale (Softball, Basketball)

Greg King- Sterling HS (Football, Athletic Director)
In his head coaching career at Sterling, his football teams went 78-28, and had 10 straight play-off appearances and 5 conference titles. In addition to his success as a football coach, he was inducted in the Illinois Athletic Director's Association HOF. Greg was elected to Illinois High School Football Coaches Association Hall of Fame in 2019.

Diane Lichtenberg- Bettendorf HS (Volleyball)
Diane coached volleyball at Bettendorf for 34 years. During that time, her teams had only one losing season while winning two State championships. She has been selected to both the National Coaches HOF and to the Iowa Volleyball HOF. 

Jim Martin- Lincolnway East (Girls Basketball)

Mark Massey- Clinton HS (Volleyball)
Mark was the head volleyball coach at Clinton for 38 years. His teams won 818 games, and twice took second in State. He is in the Iowa Volleyball HOF and Clinton HS HOF.

Jeff Parsons- Roseville, Wethersfeild, Fulton (Baseball, Basketball, Principal, Athletic Director)
Jeff was a highly successful baseball and basketball coach at Kewanee Wethersfield. He was inducted into the IBCA HOF. Presently he is the Principal and Athletic Director at Fulton

Mike Reynolds- Bismark-Henning, Galesburg, DeKalb

Larry Schulte- Sherrard, Black Hawk, Fenton, Alleman (Boys Basketball, Athletic Director)
With stops at Sherrard, Fenton, and Alleman as head coach, Coach Schulte’s teams won 353 games. Larry guided Alleman to 5 State Appearances in 1995, 1996, 1997, 2000, 2004. His ‘95 team finished 4th at State and his ‘96 team finished 3rd at State. After coaching at Alleman, he became assistant coach at Augustana College. In 2006 Coach Schulte was inducted into the IBCA HOF in 2006 and the Alleman HOF in 2014. 

Thom Sigel- Rock Falls/Rock Island HS (Golf, Boys Basketball)
Thom coached basketball for 32 years. His teams won 502 games, and he has the distinction of winning the State Title at both Rock Falls and Rock Island. Thom is in the IBCA HOF.

Brad Storm- Geneseo (Boys Basketball

Mike Tracey- Alleman, UTHS, Moline HS (Football, Athletic Director)

Mike coached football at Alleman, UT, and Moline for over 20 years. He is considered the premier football coach in WB6 history. His teams won 140 games, and twice finished second in State. Mike is in the Alleman HS HOF and the Illinois Football HOF. He was also selected Illinois AD of the Year. 

   


No comments:

Post a Comment